| Season 64 |
| Young Frankenstein | 05/2022 |
| Seven Keys to Baldpate | 02/2022 |
| The Price | 11/2021 |
| Prelude to a Kiss | 09/2021 |
| Pride And Prejudice | 07/2021 |
| Season 62 |
| Almost, Maine | 02/2020 |
| Cat on a Hot Tin Roof | 11/2019 |
| The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee | 09/2019 |
| Moonlight and Magnolias | 07/2019 |
| Season 61 |
| The Drowsy Chaperone | 05/2019 |
| Exit Laughing | 02/2019 |
| Our Town | 11/2018 |
| Miracle on South Division Street | 09/2018 |
| A Tuna Christmas | 07/2018 |
| Season 60 |
| Guys and Dolls | 05/2018 |
| You Can't Take It With You | 02/2018 |
| A Charlie Brown Christmas | 12/2017 |
| Wait Until Dark | 11/2017 |
| Bell, Book and Candle | 09/2017 |
| CP In Concert Celebrating 60 Years | 07/2017 |
| Season 59 |
| Dirty Rotten Scoundrels | 05/2017 |
| Amadeus | 02/2017 |
| A County Players Christmas | 12/2016 |
| The Last Five Years | 11/2016 |
| Laughter on the 23rd Floor | 09/2016 |
| Season 58 |
| All American Big Band Style | 06/2016 |
| Memphis | 05/2016 |
| August: Osage County | 02/2016 |
| Of Mice And Men | 11/2015 |
| The 39 Steps | 09/2015 |
| A Grand Night for Singing | 07/2015 |
| Hollywood Big Band Style | 07/2015 |
| Season 57 |
| Jesus Christ Superstar | 05/2015 |
| Boeing Boeing | 02/2015 |
| The Marvelous Wonderettes | 11/2014 |
| Doubt, A Parable | 09/2014 |
| Broadway, Big Band Style! | 07/2014 |
| Season 56 |
| Monty Python's Spamalot | 05/2014 |
| The Miracle Worker | 02/2014 |
| The Best Christmas Pageant Ever | 11/2013 |
| Bach at Leipzig | 09/2013 |
| Season 55 |
| Aida | 05/2013 |
| Born Yesterday | 02/2013 |
| Marvin's Room | 11/2012 |
| Forever Plaid | 09/2012 |
| Season 54 |
| City of Angels | 05/2012 |
| All My Sons | 02/2012 |
| Once On This Island | 11/2011 |
| Chapter Two | 09/2011 |
| Season 53 |
| My Fair Lady | 05/2011 |
| The Lion in Winter | 02/2011 |
| Godspell | 11/2010 |
| I'll Be Back Before Midnight | 09/2010 |
| Season 52 |
| The Full Monty | 05/2010 |
| Rabbit Hole | 02/2010 |
| Twelve Angry Men | 11/2009 |
| The Importance of Being Earnest | 09/2009 |
| Season 51 |
How to Succeed In Business
Without Really Trying | 05/2009 |
| String of Pearls | 02/2009 |
| Blood Brothers | 11/2008 |
| Noises Off | 09/2008 |
| Season 50 |
| County Players in Concert | 06/2008 |
| Sweeney Todd | 05/2008 |
| Nuts | 02/2008 |
| The Woman In Black | 11/2007 |
| I Hate Hamlet | 09/2007 |
| Season 49 |
| Jekyll & Hyde | 05/2007 |
| The Cocktail Hour | 02/2007 |
Joseph and the
Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat | 12/2006 |
| Greater Tuna | 09/2006 |
| The World Goes Round | 07/2006 |
| Season 48 |
| Gypsy | 05/2006 |
| Proof | 02/2006 |
| A View From The Bridge | 11/2005 |
| Sylvia | 09/2005 |
| Season 47 |
| Cabaret | 05/2005 |
| The Glass Menagerie | 02/2005 |
| Pack of Lies | 11/2004 |
| Same Time, Next Year | 09/2004 |
| Season 46 |
| Once Upon a Mattress | 05/2004 |
| Lettice and Lovage | 02/2004 |
| I Never Sang For My Father | 11/2003 |
| Morning's at Seven | 09/2003 |
| Season 45 |
| Grease | 05/2003 |
| Over the River and Through The Woods | 02/2003 |
| Broadway Bound | 11/2002 |
| Night Mother | 09/2002 |
| Season 44 |
| 1776 | 05/2002 |
| Terra Nova | 02/2002 |
| She Loves Me | 11/2001 |
| Moon Over the Brewery | 09/2001 |
| Season 43 |
| Pippin | 05/2001 |
| The Musical Comedy Murders of 1940 | 02/2001 |
| The Last Night of Ballyhoo | 11/2000 |
| The Fantasticks | 09/2000 |
| Season 42 |
| The Secret Garden | 05/2000 |
| Moon Over Buffalo | 02/2000 |
| Dancing At Lughnasa | 11/1999 |
| Baby | 09/1999 |
| Season 41 |
| Into the Woods | 05/1999 |
| Lost In Yonkers | 02/1999 |
| How the Other Half Loves | 11/1998 |
| The Twilight of the Golds | 09/1998 |
| Season 40 |
| Anything Goes | 05/1998 |
| The Runner Stumbles | 02/1998 |
| The Shadow Box | 11/1997 |
| The Sunshine Boys | 09/1997 |
| Broadway Melody | 07/1997 |
| Season 39 |
| A Chorus Line | 05/1997 |
| Deathtrap | 02/1997 |
| Inherit The Wind | 11/1996 |
Come Back to the 5 & Dime,
Jimmy Dean, Jimmy Dean | 09/1996 |
| Season 38 |
| La Cage aux Folles | 05/1996 |
| Brighton Beach Memoirs | 02/1996 |
| The Boys Next Door | 11/1995 |
| Nunsense | 09/1995 |
| Season 37 |
| Evita | 05/1995 |
| Lend Me A Tenor | 02/1995 |
| A Few Good Men | 11/1994 |
| Little Shop of Horrors | 09/1994 |
Jacques Brel is Alive and Well
and Living in Paris | 07/1994 |
| Season 36 |
| South Pacific | 05/1994 |
| Rumors | 02/1994 |
| The Nerd | 11/1993 |
| The Diary of Anne Frank | 09/1993 |
| Season 35 |
| West Side Story | 05/1993 |
| The Mousetrap | 02/1993 |
| Steel Magnolias | 11/1992 |
You're a Good Man,
Charlie Brown! | 09/1992 |
| Season 34 |
| Man of LaMancha | 05/1992 |
| Blithe Spirit | 02/1992 |
| The Foreigner | 11/1991 |
| One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest | 09/1991 |
| Season 33 |
| Camelot | 05/1991 |
| Barefoot In The Park | 02/1991 |
| Enter Laughing | 12/1990 |
A Funny Thing Happened
on the Way to the Forum | 10/1990 |
| Season 32 |
| The Mystery of Edwin Drood | 05/1990 |
| The Man Who Came To Dinner | 02/1990 |
| Fifth of July | 12/1989 |
| Look Homeward, Angel | 10/1989 |
| Season 31 |
| Oliver! | 05/1989 |
| Crimes of the Heart | 02/1989 |
| Go Back For Murder | 12/1988 |
| Company | 09/1988 |
| Season 30 |
| Hello, Dolly! | 05/1988 |
| You Can't Take It With You | 02/1988 |
| Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf? | 12/1987 |
| On Golden Pond | 10/1987 |
| They're Playing Our Song | 08/1987 |
| Season 29 |
| Fiddler on the Roof | 05/1987 |
| Witness For the Prosecution | 02/1987 |
| My Three Angels | 12/1986 |
| The Rainmaker | 10/1986 |
| Movies, Musicals and More | 07/1986 |
| Season 28 |
| Bye Bye Birdie | 05/1986 |
| Agnes of God | 11/1985 |
| Arsenic and Old Lace | 09/1985 |
| Shenanigans | 07/1985 |
| Season 27 |
| Oklahoma! | 05/1985 |
| Prisoner of Second Avenue | 02/1985 |
| Tribute | 11/1984 |
| Bus Stop | 09/1984 |
| Limelight | 07/1984 |
| Season 26 |
| The Sound of Music | 06/1984 |
| The Subject Was Roses | 03/1984 |
| Harvey | 01/1984 |
| Dracula | 10/1983 |
| Broadway Show Stoppers | 07/1983 |
| Season 25 |
| Carousel | 05/1983 |
| Ten Little Indians | 03/1983 |
| A Thousand Clowns | 01/1983 |
| A Christmas Carol | 12/1982 |
| The Little Foxes | 10/1982 |
| Season 24 |
| Brigadoon | 05/1982 |
| 6 Rms Riv Vu | 03/1982 |
| The Mousetrap | 01/1982 |
| Death of a Salesman | 11/1981 |
| A Delicate Balance | 09/1981 |
| Season 23 |
| Guys & Dolls | 05/1981 |
| Never Too Late | 02/1981 |
| California Suite | 01/1981 |
| That Championship Season | 10/1980 |
| 10 Years 10 | 09/1980 |
| The Glass Menagerie | 08/1980 |
| Season 22 |
| Kismet | 05/1980 |
| The Sunshine Boys | 02/1980 |
| A Streetcar Named Desire | 11/1979 |
| An Evening With County Players | 09/1979 |
| Twenty-Seven Wagons Full of Cotton | 07/1979 |
| Sorry Wrong Number | 07/1979 |
| Season 21 |
| Two By Two | 05/1979 |
| Picnic | 02/1979 |
| Rashomon | 11/1978 |
| An Evening With Gilbert and Sullivan | 09/1978 |
| Season 20 |
| The Yeomen of the Guard | 05/1978 |
| Toys in the Attic | 01/1978 |
| Stop the World - I Want to Get Off | 10/1977 |
| Season 19 |
| Annie Get Your Gun | 05/1977 |
| Lovers and Other Strangers | 02/1977 |
| The Last of Mrs. Lincoln | 11/1976 |
| Season 18 |
| 1776 | 05/1976 |
| The Secret Affairs of Mildred Wild | 02/1976 |
| Wait Until Dark | 10/1975 |
| Season 17 |
| The Music Man | 05/1975 |
| The Gingerbread Lady | 02/1975 |
| I Never Sang for My Father | 10/1974 |
| Season 16 |
| Fiddler on the Roof | 05/1974 |
| Everthing in the Garden | 02/1974 |
| Adaptation | 11/1973 |
| Next | 11/1973 |
| Season 15 |
| The Lion in Winter | 05/1973 |
| Come Blow Your Horn | 03/1973 |
| Gypsy | 12/1972 |
| Season 14 |
A Funny Thing Happened
on the Way to the Forum | 05/1972 |
| Cactus Flower | 02/1972 |
You Know I Can't Hear You
When the Water's Running | 11/1971 |
| Season 13 |
| Man of LaMancha | 05/1971 |
| The Odd Couple | 02/1971 |
| Separate Tables | 11/1970 |
| Season 12 |
| Funny Girl | 05/1970 |
| Don't Drink the Water | 02/1970 |
| The Typists and the Tiger | 11/1969 |
| Season 11 |
| The Mikado | 06/1969 |
| Fiorello | 05/1969 |
| Barefoot in the Park | 01/1969 |
| Death of a Salesman | 11/1968 |
| Season 10 |
| Camelot | 05/1968 |
| Mary, Mary | 02/1968 |
| A View from the Bridge | 11/1967 |
| Season 9 |
How to Succeed In Business
Without Really Trying | 05/1967 |
| Enter Laughing | 02/1967 |
| The Crucible | 11/1966 |
| Season 8 |
| Anything Goes | 06/1966 |
| Blythe Spirit | 02/1966 |
| Come Back, Little Sheba | 11/1965 |
| Season 7 |
| The King and I | 05/1965 |
| Summer and Smoke | 02/1965 |
| Critic's Choice | 11/1964 |
| Season 6 |
| Brigadoon | 05/1964 |
| Detective Story | 02/1964 |
| The Solid Gold Cadillac | 11/1963 |
| Season 5 |
| Kiss Me Kate | 05/1963 |
| Devil's Desciple | 02/1963 |
| Sabrina Fair | 11/1962 |
| Season 4 |
| South Pacific | 05/1962 |
| A Streetcar named Desire | 01/1962 |
| Romanoff and Juliet | 10/1961 |
| Season 3 |
| Guys and Dolls | 06/1961 |
| The Desperate Hours | 01/1961 |
| The Teahouse of the August Moon | 10/1960 |
| Season 2 |
| Finian's Rainbow | 05/1960 |
| Death of a Salesman | 01/1960 |
| Visit to a Small Planet | 10/1959 |
| Season 1 |
| Born Yesterday | 06/1959 |
| The Glass Menagerie | 02/1959 |
| Laura | 10/1958 |
| Season 0 |
| Bell, Book and Candle | 05/1958 |